"Honey, did you order a box of new checks via FedEx?" my wife called as she walked in the front door with the mail.
Nope, that would be the new Apple TV. There's been a lot of focus by Apple TV first responders on just how small the device is, and I've gotta admit I was wowed by its diminutive proportions (just 3.9 inches square) as I unboxed it like a Matryoshka doll.
As you can see in these pics on the right, it's significantly smaller than its previous iteration, and is also smaller than the previous generation of the Apple TV's main competition--the Roku XR streaming video box (though the Roku line has now been revamped with a sleeker design).
But its size, while something to marvel at, is ultimately rather unimportant in determining whether the Apple TV is a worthy device for your home entertainment center. The question is, does it do the job of streaming the content you want from the cloud or from your computers without many hiccups?
The New Jack Apple TV is easy peasy, lemon squeezy to set up--just plug it in, connect to your Wi-Fi network (or plug in an Ethernet cable), and start surfing the TV show and movie rental offerings. Navigate using the longer, sleekly solid aluminum remote over to the Computers heading to connect to an iTunes library using the Home Sharing feature of iTunes 10 (and entering the email address of the iTunes account you used to set up Home Sharing). Once set up, you can stream all the movies, TV Shows, podcasts, and music that you have stored on that remote computer through to the Apple TV.
Our iTunes setup has the main library stored on an HP MediaSmart home server and funneled through an original Core Solo-powered Mac mini. With our OG Apple TV, there was always a bit of a lag as streamed video content would start at the beginning but then go black for several seconds before restarting playback up about 10 to 15 seconds into the video (I was never sure whether this was down to the ATV device or the connectivity to remote computers/servers). However, the new Apple TV seemed to have a much springier stream capability from server-stored video and was fairly immediate in playback.
Before going any further, I whipped out my iPhone and fired up the newly refreshed Remote app, which provides more interactivity with the Apple TV--namely flicking your finger on your iOS device to control the ATV interface as well as typing user account/password combos far more easily than scrolling with the physical aluminum remote. I then hooked up my Netflix account and immediately started streaming an episode of Doc Martin, picking up right where I last left it when watching on my Roku the night before (the ATV asked whether I wanted to resume playing or start from the beginning).
On the Apple iTunes Store side of things, further testing included a rental episode of Glee and a full-length HD movie rental with the new release of Get Him to the Greek (testing technology can be a hard job, but someone has to do it). With both choices, streaming was nearly instantaneous. Glee played perfectly, though I noticed one or two very brief instances of onscreen blockiness due to some buffering issues while watching the latter stages of Greek.
Based on just a few days of use, can I recommend the new Apple TV? Well, it depends on several factors. If you're focused on watching movies either rented through the Apple TV, bought from iTunes and stored from a home computer, or streamed from Netflix (for subscribers only), the ATV is priced right and works as advertised--with nearly instantaneous streams from both Apple's iTunes Store and Netflix and quickly responsive streaming from networked computers.
However, if you want to watch TV shows on it, it's a bit swings and roundabouts. Due to reticence/nervousness from certain media quarters over Apple's business model for offering cheap TV rental content, you can only directly rent shows using the Apple TV from ABC, Fox, and BBC America--NBC, CBS, and other cable channels are taking a wait and see approach. Thusly, if you're a fan of 30 Rock or How I Met Your Mother, you're out of luck... sort of. You can still purchase these shows from Apple's iTunes Store (starting at $2 for standard definition versions), download them to a home computer, and then stream them to your Apple TV. But currently there's not a direct way to get them by browsing through the rental storefront on the Apple TV (where rentals are just $1).
For now, I can't wholly recommend the Apple TV to those who mainly want quick, affordable access to TV shows--at least until content providers start to get on the new Apple paradigm. Another factor in the equation is how the AirPlay feature--which enables you to stream music and video wirelessly from an iOS device--will play out when it gets implemented in the iOS 4.2 update slated for November. Will it mean that you'll be able to stream video from apps on your iPad or iPhone--such as the TV.com or Hulu Plus apps--to the Apple TV? That would be pretty sweet, but it's still a couple steps removed from just clicking a button on your remote and getting instant video stream satisfaction for just a buck.
For my uses, though, I'll be keeping and using the
new Apple TV... as well as the
old-school Apple TV, which I've hacked using the
aTV Flash package of software add-ons that allow me to play a variety of video file formats not supported by Apple. Also on the credit side for the new Apple TV--I like that it's pretty much completely noiseless, actually goes to sleep when not in use, and doesn't produce the surface-of-the-sun-like heat that the original ATV does.
The big question is whether I'll keep my Roku XR, which duplicates the new ATV's Netflix streaming capabilities but also provides access to Amazon's Video On Demand as well as other channel options. But that's a question to be answered a bit down the road once I and my wife completely sort through our video access needs.
For other views on the
new Apple TV, check out reviews at
iLounge,
Engadget,
Fox News, and
CNet.
--Agen G.N. Schmitz